Player development is complete garbage. It is one hundred percent based on a players"potential feature" instead of Madden 21 coins generation. 2k has great depth but the fundamentals are so fucked that the match style becomes a shitshow following like 2 seasons. Didn't even mention that the glitch where centres will not sign with your staff and request literal billion dollar contracts that has been in the game for 5+ years. However, the difference is that you can adjust luxury and salary size and even how much the players ask to paid.
Just how much each single feature progresses/regresses, how every stat simulates, player tendencies, change rules and even how valuable selections are to groups. In Madden you are stuck with broken contracts and CPU, in 2k you can help handle that, hell in Madden the cap does not even increase from year to year, have RFAs, tenders, exceptions etc.. The difference between the two could only be appreciated if you have tried to play with the Madden franchise.
What's garbage with development being based on a player's potential? Stat based progression is so backwards and the XP system Madden utilizes is the worst development system I've ever seen while playing football games because the 90s. Players play better since they have better, not the other way round. Madden literally does it opposite as you can. I disagree.
In 2k even if you typical 40 ppg with a 57ovr with 66 possible he will constantly just hit 66 overall (unless you send him via untapped potential of course). I get the evaluations are fairly overrated, particularly overall evaluations, but it's a little unrealistic seeing the guy averaging 40ppg at the bottom tier of players for his whole career imo. Production should be the primary factor in development viewing as that is literally the point of developing a player.
I disagree with this 100%. A reason is every other sports game does it another way and Madden is the odd person out. Can Lamar Jackson get better because he did since he got 20, he put up stats or put up stats? The system Madden utilizes is so linear and static. There is nothing dynamic about it and it is backwards. I don't play with franchise mode so I can take a 65 complete RB and cheap Madden nfl 21 coins get 3k racing yards with him and watch him develop to a 99ovr. I need to look at my settings if I am making with a 65 ovr back or I'm cheesing the match.
